30 October 2012

Comment is free


However it seems that many would seek to silence it. I know it seems strange but I would rather hear what people are saying than sit in ignorance assuming they agree. Sadly when people such as Clarkson (http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/jeremy-clarkson-blasted-for-selfish-train-280159), or Porter make comments in such poor taste and call it humour I wonder if this freedom has brought a laziness and arrogance to some people who think that no matter what they say they will be listened to and laughed with without fear of causing offence. The celebrities status has it’s downfalls however there seem to be precious few making any difference to how thoughtless people are. They apologise or retract yet still have earning power and pots of money, however if they are but entertainers then surely at some point they will hear the horror in others and wonder why?

Maybe they won’t but still it is our story that is being heard, our outrage and it’s about time it was and if it wasn’t for their thoughtlessness would our voices even be out there?

I’m guessing not however. as the trend of late is that people are speaking; they are getting the message out there http://vimeo.com/52248058 however empowering this is I find the idea of putting people who are least well equipped to deal with the media into the limelight somewhat disturbing yet it seems the only way. The number of bloggers increases daily and so many people wanting to share and be inspirational is it really fair? Shouldn’t we have champions and shouldn’t they be capable of putting our message out there without us?

But who better than us who know what it’s like.


Particularly as it seems many with celebrity status (and I am including MP’s in this) seem exempt from the problems that so plagues most of us mere mortals. They have their own particular brand of problem but somehow it really doesn’t cause the same effect. For the likes of Robert Downey Junior Manic depressive, criminal record, drugs addiction and still he gets leading roles in films and grosses out way above the average. And what of the likes of other people who go into reality TV Rehab and get paid to get treatment. There’s no waiting list there. And MP’s such as Alastair Campbell, and Kevan Jones, they seem to have bought a silence and treatment and still have secured their jobs without the frenzied problems of so many of us.

Dearly bought no doubt so is it only the people who have suffered who are speaking out?


No I guess not but it does seem that they are the ones who are getting quoted most frequently and have the most impact. So what of Ed Milliband leader of the opposition, well he’s not admitted to anything and his speech to the the Royal College of Psychiatrists was rousing and timely. Oh yes I am a cynic however I do agree with him on so many points

Mental ill-health is a cradle to grave problem with nothing like a cradle to grave service... http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2012/10/ed-milibands-speech-mental-health-full-text

And this

We have to confront the unspoken discriminations too. Like the vast inequalities in funding for research. Like the lack of training in mental health of many NHS staff – whether in GP surgeries, outpatient clinics or A&E. Eight out of ten primary care professionals say they need more training in mental health than they have. Like the lack of understanding of mental health that seems to characterise parts of the social security system. And like the willingness of governments to make the first and deepest cuts in services for mental health. Indeed, it is a very troubling sign that for the first time in a decade we have seen a cut in total spending on mental health. A reduction of £150million, including cuts in crisis services and out-reach programmes.

And this too

One encouraged by the campaign Time to Change, which has done a fantastic job in tackling mental health discrimination at work and the new Mental Health Discrimination Bill currently before Parliament.

And it’s not just business that needs to change.

The same is true in our schools.

The last Labour government placed an emphasis on the mental well-being of their students.

To give them the emotional, psychological resilience that they need.

To help them face the challenges of the twenty-first century.

However his party political snipes at the conservative party and his spiel about what they will do leave me a bit cold. It’s not that I don’t agree with him I just doubt that he will do anything.

He came under fire earlier in the year about his leadership abilities but also about his change in policies that seem to have completely reversed in recent times. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/video/2012/feb/22/nhs-miliband-cameron-pmqs-commons-reform-lansley-video This discussion highlighted many things to approve of but also to disapprove of and much as Cameron highlighted this I am unconvinced that Ed Miliband would have to deliver anything other than hope of change for him to be put into power. Cameron is missing the point that actually his reform is far from what the country wants that they are likely to vote him out on the strength of and much as some as this author in the guardian suggests

It's a brave politician in these times of hardening attitudes that takes on "the politically incorrect community". Perhaps unwittingly, Miliband has managed to get to the heart of a gnarly problem when he mentioned privilege – the perceived right enjoyed by people without mental health difficulties to speak with authority about those who do. Humour cuts right to the heart of this imbalance because it thrives on taboos, on saying the unsayable http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/29/ed-miliband-mental-health

However I do not think it brave but shrewd, since he is not only taking on politically incorrect community but saddling up with the biggest growing community in the UK today. 1 in 4 in their lifetimes, oh please, this is sure thing. The rising tide of outrage at benefit reform and the way those who are mental ill are treated within the country both at work and within the health service is almost certainly bound to give his party the boost they need.

Lets just hope a change is as good as a rest because I think that it is very much what will happen. This country is not about to roll over and become a model society without stigma, where people can and do talk freely about mental health, where money is allocated because of need within the NHS and not popularity, without a fight.

Talk is cheap and he has yet to deliver anything.

No comments:

Post a Comment